Atlas vs TrainHeroic: athletes log it, but what does the coach see?
I paid for TrainHeroic for a long time.
This October they added bodyweight tracking, and their post said "Athletes log it. Coaches see it." Honestly, that line is the whole job between sessions.
The bar only tells me part of the story. The rest is how they slept, what they ate, how they walked in, and what the lift looked like on video. If I can't see that, I'm guessing.
So here's what TrainHeroic added, what I think they do well, and how Atlas gets that full picture in front of the coach. Everything about TrainHeroic comes from their own site and help center, checked November 9, 2026.
What TrainHeroic added
Athletes can now log their bodyweight from the Training tab, see a trend graph over time, and turn it off if they don't want it [1]. Their feedback board says coaches can see it right alongside training data [2].
It sits in Athlete Pro, an optional upgrade athletes subscribe to in the app, with a 14-day trial [1][3]. Athlete Pro is also where their Readiness and Nutrition tools live [4].
Their readiness is a thoughtful piece of design. It's a pre-training survey on sleep, mood, energy, stress and soreness, averaged into a score from 1 to 5. They give the athlete feedback after the session instead of before, so it doesn't mess with their focus on the platform [5]. I like that reasoning.
Nutrition pulls calories and macros from apps like MyFitnessPal and Cronometer, and the athlete flips a switch to share it with their coach [6].
Who pays for the full picture
Here's the part that matters for a coach.
The coach pays for TrainHeroic. That's the plan you pick on their pricing page, by how many athletes you have [9].
Then, per their help docs, readiness, nutrition and bodyweight sit in Athlete Pro, a separate subscription each athlete upgrades to in the app [3][4]. So both sides of the platform pay. And what you see as the coach depends on which athletes upgraded, and for nutrition, which ones turned sharing on [6].
Atlas works one way. The coach pays for athletes on the roster, and every feature is on every plan. Athletes don't buy a second subscription to get check-ins, Oura or FatSecret. If they're on my roster, the tools are there for them.
Check-ins built for weightlifting
TrainHeroic's readiness questions are general wellness. Sleep, mood, energy, stress and soreness [5]. That works for any sport, which is the point of it.
Atlas's check-ins are built around a weightlifting session. Athletes answer a short one before each session and another after.
Before: sleep, energy, soreness and stress. After: movement quality, focus and misses. That second half is what I actually ask an athlete after a weightlifting session. How did the lifts move, were you locked in, what did you miss. Those answers chart right next to their training.
That's how I catch things early. When an athlete misses three snatches on Thursday, I can look back and see if the check-ins were telling me something on Monday.
If they connect Oura, I see sleep, HRV, resting heart rate and readiness on each session in their history. If they track food in FatSecret, I see daily calories and macros, and each day's foods by meal. If someone is cutting for a weight class or just under-eating, it usually shows up in the food log before it shows up on the bar.
The athlete connects these themselves and can disconnect any time.
When the check-in says they're cooked
Seeing it is half of it. The program also has to be able to bend.
Most athletes aren't full-time weightlifters. They have jobs, they have life, and they have stressors that show up in the gym.
In TrainHeroic, RPE is the only way to write autoregulation into a program. There are no percent ranges and no way to shift the day's percents by how the athlete feels. So what you wrote is what has to get done, unless you message the athlete and change it.
In Atlas I have options.
- RPE, like 4 × 4 @ RPE 7 to 8.
- Percent ranges, like 5 × 2 @ 78 to 82%, so the athlete has room on a slow day.
- Velocity targets.
- The feel selector. If I've turned it on, the athlete picks how they feel before training, from Trash to Crushing It, and that day's percents move 4 or 8 percent down or up. A Trash day at 80% becomes 72%. A Crushing It day becomes 88%.
They don't do any math. Today's weights are already worked out, and I don't have to send a message to make the day fit.
Seeing it while the block is still running
The old way, you write a program and hope it works out. You don't know if the block worked until it's over.
With check-ins charted next to training, I can see how an athlete is responding while there's still time to do something about it. On a heavy week, are they sleeping, are they recovered, how do they feel. How intensity moves through the block. How many reps we're doing between 60 and 70, 70 and 80, and 80 and 90 percent.
If something's off, I change it for that athlete in the middle of the block. If it's what I expected, we keep going.
Video review
Athletes in TrainHeroic can send videos, in chat or in session comments, and the coach can reply there [8]. What there isn't is an in-app video reviewer. No studio for stepping through the lift and drawing on it, the way Atlas, CoachLogik and CoachNow have one.
In Atlas athletes send clips from the workout they just logged, tagged to the movement and the sets they show. So the video comes with all the context. Their sets and reps, their makes and misses, how they felt, and their pre-lift questionnaire, sent straight to the coach with it. I never have to go hunting for anything else to know what I'm looking at.
Then I go frame by frame, draw on it, talk over it, and the review goes straight back into the athlete's thread.
Athletes can also comment on any exercise, and those comments go straight to their coach.
Their meets are already there
TrainHeroic is built for a lot of sports. Atlas is built for weightlifting, so meets get their own place.
Every MeetCal result shows up on the athlete's page. All six attempts, the best of each lift and the total, with PRs marked. When I write the next block, the last meet is already in front of me, and paid plans include a MeetCal subscription for every coach, roster athlete and guardian.
I wrote about the program builder itself, the calendar plus the progression view, in its own post.
Where TrainHeroic is better
I'd be lying if I said Atlas wins everywhere.
The Marketplace. You can sell your programming to athletes anywhere in the world through the TrainHeroic Marketplace, under your own brand [7]. That's their big one, and Atlas doesn't have it.
The Marketplace gets your programs in front of athletes who would never have found you. The tradeoff is that TrainHeroic takes a share of what you sell there. Per their seller terms, when a sale comes through their Marketplace Match, TrainHeroic keeps 30% of it. When you drive the sale yourself through your own link, you pay a smaller flat fee per client per month instead. Card processing fees come on top of both [17][18].
Atlas doesn't have a marketplace. What I do instead is sell group programming through my own channels. If your club already sells memberships or a remote program on its own website, point that checkout at the group's webhook, directly or through a tool like Zapier. Every time someone pays, they get added to the Atlas group. When they cancel, they get removed. Nobody has to click through each one.
Atlas takes no percentage of your sales. You keep every dollar. Every plan includes 10 group members, and past that it's a flat add-on per block of 50 members, never a cut of what you sell. Group members don't count toward your athlete limit either.
A daily bodyweight log. If you want athletes logging bodyweight in the app with a trend graph, TrainHeroic has that now, for athletes on Athlete Pro [1].
If you need the Marketplace today, go use it.
Try it
TrainHeroic has a 14-day trial. Atlas doesn't have a trial. The Free plan is the trial, and it has no time limit.
Start Free at atlas.meetcal.app, invite your first 5 athletes, and turn on check-ins. Look at their charts after four weeks. Questions, email me at maddisen@meetcal.app.
Sources
Atlas facts checked November 9, 2026. TrainHeroic facts are from their own site and help center, checked November 9, 2026.
- TrainHeroic help, Tracking Bodyweight In-App: https://support.trainheroic.com/hc/en-us/articles/49089305958413-Tracking-Bodyweight-In-App
- TrainHeroic feedback board, Track Body Metrics (marked completed Oct 6, 2026): https://peaksware.uservoice.com/forums/942745-trainheroic-customer-feedback/suggestions/45224071-track-body-metrics
- TrainHeroic help, Athlete Pro Subscriptions and Access: https://support.trainheroic.com/hc/en-us/articles/18156523992077-For-Athletes-Athlete-Pro-Subscriptions-and-Access
- TrainHeroic help, Athlete Pro section: https://support.trainheroic.com/hc/en-us/sections/17996086828045-Athlete-Pro
- TrainHeroic help, Athlete Pro: Readiness: https://support.trainheroic.com/hc/en-us/articles/18156547276557-Athlete-Pro-Readiness
- TrainHeroic help, Athlete Pro: Nutrition: https://support.trainheroic.com/hc/en-us/articles/39620825088141-Athlete-Pro-Nutrition
- TrainHeroic for coaches: https://www.trainheroic.com/coach/
- TrainHeroic help, How can I send in a video for a form check?: https://support.trainheroic.com/hc/en-us/articles/18171037417101-How-can-I-send-in-a-video-for-a-form-check
- TrainHeroic pricing: https://www.trainheroic.com/pricing/
- Atlas Questionnaires: https://atlas.meetcal.app/features/questionnaires
- Atlas Connections: https://atlas.meetcal.app/features/connections
- Atlas Training: https://atlas.meetcal.app/features/training
- Atlas Messaging and Video Review: https://atlas.meetcal.app/features/messaging
- Atlas Analytics: https://atlas.meetcal.app/features/analytics
- Atlas Meets and Competition: https://atlas.meetcal.app/features/meets
- Atlas Pricing: https://atlas.meetcal.app/pricing
- TrainHeroic help, Marketplace Seller Terms and Payment Information (checked Nov 9, 2026): https://support.trainheroic.com/hc/en-us/articles/18156808889997-Marketplace-Seller-Terms-Payment-Information
- TrainHeroic, Become a seller: https://www.trainheroic.com/become-a-seller/
- Atlas Groups: https://atlas.meetcal.app/features/groups